Social Security decisions can be complex, especially for small business owners navigating unique financial considerations. For many, the question arises: should a business owner put their spouse on the payroll to help them qualify for Social Security benefits? Clayton Shum, an experienced financial advisor, explains that while this might seem beneficial at first glance, the answer requires a deeper look into tax implications, benefit structures, and long-term financial outcomes.
Understanding Social Security for Spouses with Clayton K Shum
When business owners consider paying their spouse a salary, the primary goal is often to secure eligibility for Social Security benefits based on the spouse's own work record. Spouses who do not have a work history can typically qualify for a spousal benefit equal to 50% of the primary earner's benefit. However, as Clayton Shum points out, this benefit calculation raises important questions about whether paying additional Social Security taxes to establish an independent benefit for the spouse is worth the investment.
For instance, the amount of additional Social Security tax paid might not yield a significantly higher benefit than the spousal benefit already available. Understanding this trade-off is crucial to making informed payroll decisions that align with both immediate business needs and long-term retirement planning.
Calculating Social Security Benefits
Clayton Shum advises business owners to evaluate the financial impact of paying a salary to a spouse using tools like the Social Security Administration's Detailed Calculator. In a hypothetical scenario, if a business owner, Jerry, has consistently paid himself the maximum Social Security wage base but his spouse, Jamie, has no earnings record, their combined Social Security benefits will depend heavily on their payroll strategy.
If Jerry continues to earn the maximum salary and Jamie draws no salary, she would qualify for a spousal benefit worth 50% of Jerry's benefit. However, adding Jamie to the payroll, even at a modest salary, might increase their tax burden significantly without proportionately increasing her benefit. Clayton K Shum explains that this scenario often results in negligible financial gains, making the additional payroll taxes an unnecessary expense.
Exploring Alternative Salary Arrangements
Another approach involves assigning the primary earner's salary to the spouse. For example, if Jerry reduces his salary and Jamie earns the maximum Social Security wage base instead, the combined Social Security benefit might remain relatively unchanged. However, as Clayton Shum notes, this strategy could reduce survivor benefits for the spouse if the primary earner passes away first. Such adjustments require careful consideration of both immediate and future financial needs, particularly for couples planning for survivor benefits.
Balancing Payroll and Tax Efficiency
Clayton K Shum emphasizes the importance of balancing payroll strategies with the self-employment taxes associated with Social Security and Medicare. Business owners pay both the employer and employee shares of these taxes, totaling 15.3% on salary, with the bulk going toward Social Security. While Medicare taxes do not result in higher benefits, Social Security taxes do—though only up to a point. Therefore, determining the optimal salary for both spouses requires evaluating how much additional tax liability is worth incurring for a relatively small increase in benefits.
Personalized Social Security Planning with Clayton K Shum
Every family’s financial situation is unique, and Social Security decisions should be personalized to reflect long-term goals. Clayton Shum advises business owners to explore different payroll scenarios using the Social Security Administration's tools to estimate the impact of various salary arrangements. For example, assigning earnings to the spouse with a minimal or nonexistent work record may seem advantageous in some cases, but the additional tax burden could outweigh the benefits.
The Value of Strategic Financial Advice with Clayton K Shum
Ultimately, as Clayton K Shum explains, the decision to pay a spouse a salary should be based on a thorough analysis of costs, benefits, and long-term financial objectives. Consulting with a knowledgeable financial professional is key to understanding how Social Security rules apply to individual circumstances and ensuring that payroll decisions align with broader retirement planning goals.
In conclusion, the complexities of Social Security require careful planning, especially for small business owners. Clayton Shum underscores the importance of evaluating all options before making significant payroll decisions involving spouses. By analyzing potential outcomes and seeking expert advice, business owners can make informed choices that support both immediate needs and long-term financial security.
The information provided should not be relied upon in isolation for the purpose of making an investment decision. You must also consider the objectives, risks, charges, and expenses associated with an investment service, product or strategy prior to making an investment decision. Prior to making any investment or financial decision, an investor should seek advice from a financial, legal, tax and other professional that consider all of the particular facts and circumstances of an investor’s situation. The opinions expressed and material provided are for information purposes only and is not an offer, recommendation, or solicitation of any product, strategy or transaction. Any views, strategies or products discussed may not be appropriate or suitable for all individuals and are subject to risks.
Investment and insurance products offered are not insured by the FDIC or any other federal government agency, are not deposits or other obligations of, or guaranteed by, a bank or any bank affiliate, and are subject to investment risks, including possible loss of the principal amount invested.
Brokerage and investment advisory services are offered through Aegis Capital Corporation, a member of FINRA and SIPC.
Please use this link to view Aegis Capital Corp Risk Disclosures and Form CRS (Customer Relationship Summary).
